Replacing vs. Repairing Bathroom Cabinet Hinges: Which Is Best?

Jan 23, 2024

amerock hinges

When it comes to maintaining and updating your bathroom, one area that often gets overlooked is the cabinet hinges. These small but important components play a crucial role in the function and overall appearance of your bathroom cabinets. Over time, hinges can become loose, worn out, or outdated, affecting both the functionality and aesthetic appeal of your cabinets. In such cases, you may have to make a decision: should you replace the hinges altogether or repair them? In this blog post, we will explore the pros and cons of each option to help you make an informed decision. So, let’s dive in and discuss the various cabinet hinges available and their benefits and drawbacks.

Understanding the Types of Cabinet Hinges

Before we compare the advantages and disadvantages of replacement and repair, it’s important to familiarize ourselves with the different types of cabinet hinges. Each hinge type offers unique features and benefits. Here are some common types of cabinet hinges you may come across:

  • Butt Hinges: These are the most common type of cabinet hinge and are visible on the side of the cabinet when the door is closed. To accommodate them properly, they require a mortise cut into the cabinet and door.
  • European (Concealed) Hinges: These hinges are hidden from view when the cabinet door is closed, creating a clean and seamless appearance. They are often used in contemporary and modern designs.
  • Pivot Hinges: Pivot hinges allow the cabinet door to swing open and close on a pivot point. They are often used for full-height, two-door cabinets.
  • Overlay Hinges: These hinges are installed on the outside surface of the cabinet frame and allow the door to partially overlay the frame.
  • Inset Hinges: Inset hinges are installed inside the cabinet frame, allowing the door to sit flush with the frame. They offer a clean and customized look.
  • Continuous (Piano) Hinges: These hinges run along the entire length of the door and cabinet, providing extra support. They are commonly used for heavy or tall doors.


The Pros and Cons of Replacing Cabinet Hinges

Replacing your bathroom cabinet hinges with new ones can provide several advantages. Firstly, it allows for a complete overhaul in terms of appearance. By choosing a different type or finish for your hinges, you can significantly enhance the visual appeal of your bathroom cabinets. Additionally, if the old hinges were causing functionality issues, replacing them can improve the smoothness of opening and closing the cabinet doors.
However, there are a few disadvantages to consider. Replacing hinges can be a costly endeavor, especially if you have a large number of cabinets in your bathroom. Not only will you have to purchase new hinges, but you may also need to hire a professional to install them correctly. Additionally, finding an exact match can be challenging if you have custom-made cabinets requiring specific hinges.

The Pros and Cons of Repairing Cabinet Hinges

Repairing your existing bathroom cabinet hinges is a more expensive alternative to replacement. However, this option is particularly ideal if the hinges are still in good working condition but have become loose due to wear and tear. With a few adjustments or tightening of screws, you can restore the functionality of your hinges without having to spend a significant amount of money.

Repairing hinges also saves you the hassle of finding an exact match, especially if custom cabinets require specific hinge sizes or finishes. You can retain the existing look of your bathroom cabinets while ensuring their functionality is back to normal.

However, there are limitations to repair. If the hinges are severely damaged or are beyond repair due to age or excessive use, repairing them may only offer a temporary solution. In such cases, replacement might be necessary to prevent further issues in the future.

Making the Decision: When to Replace or Repair

Deciding whether to replace or repair your bathroom cabinet hinges ultimately depends on your circumstances. Here are a few factors to consider:

  • Condition of the Hinges: Assess the overall condition of the hinges. Replacement might be your best option if they are severely damaged or non-functional. However, repairing them can be feasible if they are structurally sound and only require minor adjustments.
  • Budget: Take into account your budget and the cost associated with either option. If you are looking for a cost-effective solution, replacement is generally the better choice. However, a repair may be more suitable if you have the budget for it.
  • Aesthetic Considerations: Consider the aesthetic impact of your decision. Replacement allows for a fresh look with various options to choose from while repairing maintains the current appearance of your cabinets.
    If you prefer a budget-friendly approach, replacement should be your first choice. However, replacement becomes necessary if the hinges are still in decent condition.

Cabinet Hardware Can Help

Cabinet Hardware is here to assist you if you’ve decided to repair or replace your bathroom cabinet hinges. Whether you need assistance with repair or refinishing, our team of experts at Cabinet Hardware can provide the solutions you need. Contact us today to learn how to send you cabinet hinges in for repair!